Home ArticlesDraft Set 2026 Retrospective Part 2: Baratheon through Night’s Watch

Draft Set 2026 Retrospective Part 2: Baratheon through Night’s Watch

by Benjamin Damm
1 views

Hey Thrones Community,

We’re continuing our 1-year retrospective today by taking a look at the Draft Packs. If you want to compare, you can find last year’s pre-launch reviews here.

Click here for part 1: Draft Starter

Once again, we’re rating cards on a 1-5 scale representing how likely you will end up including each card in your draft deck. Hereโ€™s the scale with some examples from the Valyrian Draft Set for comparison:

5 โ€“ A very powerful card that will almost always make the cut in your final deck. Either a standalone wincon or incredible utility. Examples: Feast or Famine, Victarion Greyjoy
4 โ€“ A buildaround wincon, good standalone body, or a helpful but fair utility card youโ€™re happy to play in most decks. Examples: Arya Stark, Silent Sisters
3 โ€“ A perfectly playable card that you wonโ€™t mind picking and playing most of the time but wonโ€™t win you the game on its own. Examples: Even Handed Justice, Red Cloaks
2 โ€“ Mediocre filler card that will often end up getting cut unless youโ€™re short on playables or have some specific synergies that it enables. Examples: Salty Navigator, Unsworn Apprentice
1 โ€“ Bad filler that you actively want to avoid picking and playing in your deck. Examples: Without His Beard, Crone of Vaes Dothrak

Additionally the pre-release averages will be noted alongside the new ratings like this: (2.4 ↗️ 3.6)

With that out of the way, let’s take a look at the Draft Packs!

Baratheon

[Rare] Stannis Baratheon (4.4 ↗️ 4.6)

Werner – 5 out of 5
Renown, strong effect. The downside is that you need to make sure you run enough non-limited locations. Good ones are often hard to come by.

Ululak – 5 out of 5
Would always grab him. Finding 1-2 non-limiteds is feasible, and kneeling feels strong in draft, plus renown.

Xelcor – 4 out of 5
He is great when he works, but i had some drafts just not finding the location to use him.
So might not be a first pick or you have to draft around him a bit.

Sara – 5 out of 5
The ability seems really strong, with having printed renown it works like intimidate at minimum. The downside is that he needs a non-limited location to work, but Baratheron has a great option for that in the Nightfort Ruins. 7-costers feel especially expensive in draft since you canโ€™t cheat them in with Manning, but I think in this case itโ€™s a fair cost for the ability.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 4 out of 5
Love this guy. Heโ€™s a powerful bomb that you should almost always grab if you see it. Heโ€™s slightly below the power level of some other bombs simply because his ability requires you to draft enough non-limited locations to make him consistent. But if you can, heโ€™s awesome. Donโ€™t forget that he also triggers when your opponents gain or move power!

[Common] Myrish Pirates (3.4 ↗️ 3.6)

Werner – 4 out of 5
Solid card, steals power from characters without any condition. Works great with Stannis Baratheon.

Ululak – 4 out of 5
Situationally good for that power grab and with 4 traits to combo with others; also a 4-cost char. Somehow ended up never playing them because shadows cost are steep.

Xelcor – 3 out of 5
Lots of traits. Okay body, but i saw some games turn around with the power or gold on this.
But probably mostly in the shadow agenda.

Sara – 4 out of 5
These guys seem to have a lot going for them. I only played against it one time and it seemed really strong. Moving power ability is similar to Sparrows for only one more gold, but it is a better body and it has the flexibility of messing with opponentโ€™s bestow. That alone makes it a solid option without having additional synergies in the deck. The Mercenary trait gives you the option to cheat it into play and really make the most of the gold-moving ability. The other three traits it has can all be relevant as well. It is possible that the ability would not be relevant in some games, but at least from my experience not very often.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 3 out of 5
Pretty good card, mainly just a trait bot that can fit in whatever Join Forces deck you happen to be drafting. But also a pretty strong shadows effect, if a little bit expensive. I think this guy really shines if you can find ways to jump him in via Mercenary synergies rather than paying 5 gold for him.

[Common] Nightfort Ruins (3.6 ↘️ 2.4)

Werner – 1 out of 5
More of a cheap token card in case you need a non-limited location to trigger other effects. Niche use to increase reserve for Old Tattersalt and Samwell Tarly.

Ululak – 2 out of 5
Mostly functioned as a 0-cost non-limited location. Filler in bestow or location decks, otherwise a weak use of 2 gold.

Xelcor – 4 out of 5
Great card, can give you a big boost for power challenges. Also helps with all the โ€žkneel non limited stuffโ€œ because it doesn’t matter if its knelt or not. Some other locations struggle with that a bit.

Sara – 3 out of 5
In the draft you want to find some non-limited locations for many abilities and this one is a very good and efficient option.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 2 out of 5
I think this card is fine, but not one Iโ€™m usually looking to draft early in a pack. Its main use case is being a 0-cost non-limited location, for all the cards that synergize with that. Iโ€™ve rarely seen it bestowed, but if you can afford it the effect is definitely nice.

[Common] Flaming Sword (3.0 ↗️ 3.2)

Werner – 3 out of 5
Solid one-off if you run stand or non-kneelers.

Ululak – 2 out of 5
1 gold for a power icon and intimidate, but often gone after one attack. A good combat trick if you can stand the character. Can be fun with Gendry.

Xelcor – 5 out of 5
Just a great card, you can keep it a bit if you only wanna defend with the char, and its a great card to pair with Biting Cold to save them. Intimidate is great, 1 gold for setup is great.

Sara – 3 out of 5
One phase of intimidate is not bad, especially if itโ€™s on a character that will go into multiple challenges. On paper it has nice synergy with Gendry, but you need to find at least one more weapon and then also limit yourself to only non-loyals, so I donโ€™t think it would be very likely to make it work.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 3 out of 5
I like this card a lot. Itโ€™s a little bit expensive for just a 1-off intimidate, but it really shines if you can use it alongside No Song So Sweet to add the character to the challenge without declaring it as an attacker.

[Rare] Euron Crow’s Eye (4.6 ↘️ 3.6)

Werner – 2 out of 5
Draft decks contain most of the time a lot of characters, so that effect will trigger less than you would hope for.

Ululak – 3 out of 5
Sounds stronger than he is IMHO. Expensive and rarely hits as non-character pillage for power is rare. Intimidate is great; but needs other pillage characters to be great.

Xelcor – 4 out of 5
I am not the biggest fan of 7 costers anymore. The gap to 6 coster is so big because Manning the City Walls can give them to you for โ€žfreeโ€œ but with 7 costers you have to pay a lot…. I saw them very little actually (ofc they are rare as well); in Greyjoy I think two cheaper cards are always better.

Sara – 4 out of 5
He is comparable to Stannis with the same stats and icons and a comparable ability. Euron seems slightly worse than Stannis, since his power gain triggers are mostly random, so might not trigger at all, and intimidate is much less flexible than Stannisโ€™s ability.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 5 out of 5
I think this guy is excellent. Anytime Iโ€™ve seen him played, heโ€™s been a major threat on the board, and if you build your deck around pillage, he really accelerates your game quite heavily.

[Common] Saltcliffe Marauder (3.2 ↗️ 4.0)

Werner – 4 out of 5
Solid and flexible card. Cannot hurt to have a few in your deck.

Ululak – 4 out of 5
Cheap MIL/INT pillage body that has stealth and can hand out stealth. Great with the bestow agenda or Ser Harys Swyft who seems always available.

Xelcor – 5 out of 5
This is one of Greyjoy’s best chuds by quite a lot. Raider + Drowned God is mostly only good for Greyjoy but you can do so many things with them. If you get Saltcliffe you have basically two stealths per turn. And such a great card for mill decks, you can always push a challenge through.

Sara – 3 out of 5
Decent body with stealth. Probably a bit on the expensive side with the bestow, and giving stealth is only temporary. Still, I would be happy to take it when I could include it in the deck Iโ€™m drafting.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 4 out of 5
I like this guy quite a lot, and if you pick up the right cards to get your Greyjoy bestow package to work together, he can really be a terror. And pillage is a scary keyword in draft!

[Common] Stony Shore Thrall (1.6 ↗️ 2.6)

Note: this card was slightly changed for the 2026 edition.

Werner – 3 out of 5
Playable for the body. Choke / mill can work, so solid card for these decks.

Ululak – 2 out of 5
Sounds good, but never made them work; too narrow for most decks.

Xelcor – 3 out of 5
This is probably not more than a 3… but when you have five of them, it gets wild. If the opponent is permanent on 2 reserve that’ss something. Also their own jumpers work against them; you don’t even need to play your own. Best combo is with Cast Me Forth, because you can replay and trigger the same one after MIL claim.

Sara – 2 out of 5
Ability is not good, but itโ€™s a perfectly good chud if you need cheap filler and just play it blank.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 3 out of 5
This guy has good traits and solid stats for the cost. But his ability kind of doesnโ€™t do anything until youโ€™ve drafted like five of these and then you get a crazy combo turn to wipe out your opponentโ€™s hand. Have I seen that happen? Yes. Is it worth building your deck around? Debatable.

[Common] Kraken’s Hatchet (4.6 ↘️ 3.0)

Werner – 4 out of 5
Expensive stand, but if you have strong characters probably worth to run one.

Ululak – 3 out of 5
Good in Raiders / bestow decks. Raider trait and a stand after an attacker win. Very much depends on the build.

Xelcor – 3 out of 5
If you have Saltcliffe or Left-Hand Lucas this immediately jumps to a 5 and is the best attachment in the game. Without I think it isn’t that great, but normally if you get one you get the rest as well. Greyjoy draft looks pretty open.

Sara – 3 out of 5
Really good ability but not cheap.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 2 out of 5
Itโ€™s a decent card, but doesnโ€™t really do much unless you can get some bestow synergies cooking. Thereโ€™s definitely support in the draft pool to make this card sing, but by itself paying 2 gold for a stand feels a little bit expensive unless youโ€™ve got this on a 7-cost bomb. 

[Rare] Tommen Baratheon (2.6 ↘️ 2.2)

Werner – 2 out of 5
There is only a total of three printed Cats. Of course you can still create various additional Cats through trait manipulation, but most of the time probably not worth the hassle.

Ululak – 2 out of 5
Havenโ€™t seen him work – needs too many Cats – but really, really want to *meow*. Will never be my first rare pick if others are available.

Xelcor – 2 out of 5
It’s cute, but actually getting the Cats is hard. And if you have to play Faceless Men you are already in a bad spot.

Sara – 2 out of 5
Fun card that I would love to play in standard joust. In draft it feels unlikely you will get much out of his ability since thereโ€™s only three printed Cats in the pool, which are all uncommon and Tommen himself is rare. In theory you can get more Cats with any of the trait manipulation cards, but it doesnโ€™t really feel worth it. 

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 3 out of 5
How can you not love Catboy Tommen? Heโ€™s pretty decent if you draft enough Cats to get him to the 2-Cat level, as draw can be rare in draft. And donโ€™t forget, you can make him a Cat himself with the U&U agenda or cards like Face Mask. Live the Cat horde mini-voltron dream!

[Common] Eager Opportunist (3.6 ↘️ 3.4)

Werner – 3 out of 5
Solid card, good for aggressive builds. Especially if you run Behold our Bounty.

Ululak – 3 out of 5
Not played yet, but think you can make him work with enough bestow sources available. Could be great for tempo.

Xelcor – 3 out of 5
It’s a good card to set up some jumpers, but you want some form of recursion for the gold. Otherwise it might be a bit expensive.

Sara – 4 out of 5
Ability seems really strong with Seeking Fortunes, but even without it, it’s a 3 cost bicon that for one extra gold brings in another body.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 4 out of 5
Even if you only give this guy 1 charge and trigger him once, heโ€™s still really strong! Great way to jump in Myrish Pirates for some surprise stealing. But if youโ€™re running the bestow agenda, youโ€™ll want as many of this guy as you can find. Jumpers are really strong in draft since econ is tight.

[Common] Cruel Brigand (3.2 ↗️ 3.4)

Werner – 3 out of 5
Strong card for aggressive builds. Can really mess with your board.

Ululak – 3 out of 5
Can see nice combos in attrition decks, bouncing cheap chars back to ownerโ€™s hand to claim the good stuff. Else, the faction kneel can conflict with agendas.

Xelcor – 5 out of 5
One of the best chuds in the game, targeted removal for 3 gold is great, and it is โ€ženters playโ€œ so some cheat effects also work on it. Additionally the Knight trait is pretty good, and Raider is great for mill decks to get some control. 2 gold for a 2 STR bicon is also pretty okay.

Sara – 3 out of 5
I drafted this card often, mostly just for the trait and cost, but havenโ€™t used the ability that much. It can be a bit awkward to use since it has a condition and also needs a faction kneel, but it can still be very impactful in the right circumstance.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 3 out of 5
Love the art on this guy. Gives off a truly fantastic amount of scumbag energy. And heโ€™s got awesome traits and good stats! Iโ€™ve only triggered his effect a handful of times, but sometimes it can really put the hurt on the opponent if you can combine it with claim raise and other aggro tools.

[Common] Silverhill River (4.2 ↗️ 4.4)

Werner – 4 out of 5
Non-limited economy that can close the game for you. Especially strong if you need non-limited locations to enable other cards such as Robb Stark, Stannis Baratheon,โ€ฆ

Ululak – 4 out of 5
Extra income, so default 4/5 already. Small chance for a power gain to close.

Xelcor – 5 out of 5
I would pick this card if i would ever see one, more of it being a non limited econ card. But the effect is also great at the end of the game.

Sara – 4 out of 5
This is a perfect utility card that I love to take whenever I see it. Non-limited location that is also an econ card and can help you close the game, couldnโ€™t ask much more of a 2-cost common location.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 5 out of 5
Iโ€™ve said it a thousand times and Iโ€™m not done yet – econ is tight in draft. So non-limited econ with an upside? Be still my heart! This card is the main reason to play the Seeking Fortunes agenda, imo. If you can pick up two or three of these, you can build a pretty substantial gold advantage on your opponent, and you will definitely feel how strong that is. And the fact that you can convert it into power on the last turn that you push for the win is just gravy. Love this card.

[Rare] Arianne Martell (4.4 ↘️ 4.0)

Werner – 3 out of 5
Expensive for the text. Rather playable for the Insight. Gets more interesting if you can sneak her in with Eager Opportunist or Quentyn Martell.

Ululak – 4 out of 5
Insight on a 4-cost char, plus icon steal and giving an icon to all your non-Martell chars as a strong trick makes her quite versatile.

Xelcor – 4 out of 5
The insight is great, but paying 4 gold each turn can be a bit bad sometimes and not sustainable for some decks.

Sara – 4 out of 5
Very strong ability especially if you get her along with Mellario, or even better, some of the cards that cheat her into play. Without that it might get too expensive to use her ability all the time, but then sheโ€™s there to draw for insight.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 5 out of 5
Very strong card. Even just for the insight, sheโ€™s great for her cost. And the effect is fantastic. She shines in decks with three or more factions, or just with fewer Martell cards overall. Sheโ€™s pretty much a snap-pick for me if I see her.

[Common] Starfall Servant (3.4 ➡️ 3.4)

Werner – 3 out of 5
Quite expensive, gold is tight in Draft. But can be an okayish body – but I am not convinced of icon control as a viable strategy in Draft.

Ululak – 3 out of 5
Fair value for money with two icons, stealth and the ability to disable opponents. But shadow (3) still is pricey.

Xelcor – 4 out of 5
The stealth on power is pretty big if you wanna win like normal people. 5 gold for the effect is expensive but it for sure is worth it.

Sara – 3 out of 5
I would compare it to Saltcliffe Marauder, since itโ€™s a non-unique with stealth that costs you 4 gold. This one has non-conditional stealth but it doesnโ€™t have the flexibility of marshalling it for only 3 when you need that. The icon control is comparable to giving another character stealth, but is less repeatable and also more expensive. Still, I would say itโ€™s about on the same level.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 4 out of 5
Very strong card. Stealth is pretty fantastic in this format, and her icon-steal ability basically means she stealths two characters by herself on the turn she comes out. Great pickup, especially in a Shadows deck.

[Common] Desert Freerider (2.6 ↘️ 2.4)

Werner – 3 out of 5
Okayish filler for the stats, still not convinced of icon control in Draft.

Ululak – 1 out of 5
Body or filler.

Xelcor – 2 out of 5
It’s a Mercenary + Raider, 2 for two icons 2 STR isn’t the worst. But not the best overall.

Sara – 3 out of 5
Like the other 2-cost bicons, itโ€™s decent just for the stats. The ability is okay and I like that it has the flexibility of adding or removing an icon.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 3 out of 5
Same as most of these 2-cost bicons, heโ€™s got good traits. Unfortunately his ability is a bit mid. But heโ€™s a solid 2-drop for your Seeking Fortunes deck.

[Common] Vengeful Lordling (2.6 ➡️ 2.6)

Werner – 3 out of 5
Nice filler if you run some Shadows or Ambush. Stats are fine, chud, two icons.

Ululak – 2 out of 5
Could be decent in shadows/ambush builds but havenโ€™t tried yet.

Xelcor – 2 out of 5
It’s mediocre.

Sara – 3 out of 5
Another good chud that is easy to include and itโ€™s kinda an econ card. The only problem with it is that you canโ€™t rely on it too much, because the opponent could play around it.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 3 out of 5
Fun card. I wish there was more synergy in the format with his Lord trait – Iโ€™ve always had a pipe-dream of drafting a Lords tribal deck with Join Forces, but that has yet to materialize. I think he shines the most in a Shadows deck, so definitely try to pick up a few if youโ€™re drafting for that.

[Rare] Melisandre (4.2 ↘️ 4.0)

Werner – 5 out of 5
This will ask questions your opponent needs to answer. Even more brutal if you can cheat in chars that would leave play anyways. And then: Insight on top.

Ululak – 4 out of 5
5 STR insight, and the character steal can swing the board each round with enough fodder to pay the price. 7 cost is the only caveat.

Xelcor – 2 out of 5
NW cards… what should i say, i saw a lot of them in drafts, as the last 5 cards of each pack unpicked. Pretty sure i had a game having 3 Mels going around till somebody had to pick her. It is so costly and might not even work sometimes.

Sara – 5 out of 5
This card scares me. She basically has a somewhat limited, but repeatable targeted kill effect that ignores all dupes and saves. And if the opponent has low-cost characters that gain power she could also make a huge power swing at the same time. And she also has insight. I admit I never saw her in practice, so it might be that the ability is more limiting or awkward to use than it seems on paper.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 4 out of 5
I think sheโ€™s very scary, but takes a bit of elbow grease to make her ability work. Itโ€™s a dream of mine to make a jumpers deck that abuses her steal ability. If you canโ€™t make good use of her ability, then sheโ€™s a bit too expensive for just insight.

[Common] Tormund’s Horde (2.8 ↗️ 3.0)

Werner – 3 out of 5
Solid card if you run an aggressive build or want to focus on pillage. Intimidate might also com in handy.

Ululak – 4 out of 5
5 STR intimidate army for 5, plus mill / draw after attacking win. The MIL only icon keeps it from being better.

Xelcor – 3 out of 5
This is the secret pick for a specific archetype. Also it has great traits (outside of Wildling, not even sure what it could do). Biggest trait is Army with Windblown, standing them is kinda good.

Sara – 1 out of 5
Intimidate is nice, but itโ€™s too expensive for a monocon and the ability is meh except if you are trying to mill (which, to be fair, turns out is easier in draft than normal joust).

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 4 out of 5
Honestly very solid, which is not what Iโ€™d expect from a 5 cost monocon. But Iโ€™ve seen this guy pop off before. And holy trait bot Batman, what a combo!

[Common] Abel’s Washerwoman (2.6 ➡️ 2.6)

Werner – 3 out of 5
Nice filler card if you run some non-limited locations already.

Ululak – 4 out of 5
4-cost, hands out pillage or stealth and allows on-demand kneeling of non-limited location is very strong in the right decks (Moon Door, anyone?).

Xelcor – 1 out of 5
I have never seen this Woman in my life. Probably should be a 2/3 if it wasn’t a NW card.

Sara – 2 out of 5
Kinda fits in the same slot with Starfall Servant and Saltcliffe Marauder as a 4 cost with stealth. This one is the most repeatable, but needs another card to have stealth at all, which makes it a lot worse to me. In my first draft, I took it thinking it would be great with Dywen, Benjen and Great Ranging, but turns out I massively overrated how much econ is available in draft.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 3 out of 5
Sheโ€™s very solid by herself if you draft enough non-limiteds. But if you draft Moon Door, her value goes through the roof! Youโ€™ll definitely be hunting for two or three of these if youโ€™ve managed to snag The Door.

[Common] Wall-Bound Knight (2.2 ↗️ 3.0)

Werner – 3 out of 5
Quite expensive for the effect. Most of the times played probably for the stats and the traits: Knights and The Seven have nice synergies.

Ululak – 3 out of 5
Kinda meh at first glance, but cheap, good traits, and can finance a shadows build.

Xelcor – 2 out of 5
I only see this card if I have a play that needs excatly 1 gold after a challenge, and I am always sad. But still a NW card so sadly a downgrade by default.

Sara – 3 out of 5
Another 2-cost bicon, so already a decent start. The shadow ability has the potential to really ruin opponentโ€™s game plan, and if you have use for the money it steals it only costs one more than just marshalling it.

Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 4 out of 5
Honestly love this guy more than most of the other 2-cost bicons. Knight and The Seven are two of the strongest traits in the pool. Iโ€™ve rarely used his effect, but it can also be very strong in the right moment.

Card Averages

Overperformers (up from last year)

Stony Shore Thrall (+1.0)
Saltcliffe Marauder (+0.8)
Wall-Bound Knight (+0.8)
Silverhill River (+0.2)
Myrish Pirates (+0.2)
Flaming Sword (+0.2)
Tormund’s Horde (+0.2)
Stannis Baratheon (+0.2)
Cruel Brigand (+0.2)

Underperformers (down from last year)

Kraken’s Hatchet (-1.6)
Nightfort Ruins (-1.2)
Euron Crow’s Eye (-1.0)
Arianne Martell (-0.4)
Tommen Baratheon (-0.4)
Melisandre (-0.2)
Eager Opportunist (-0.2)
Desert Freerider (-0.2)

Card Averages

4.6 Stannis Baratheon
4.4 Silverhill River
4.0 Saltcliffe Marauder
4.0 Arianne Martell
4.0 Melisandre
3.6 Myrish Pirates
3.6 Euron Crow’s Eye
3.4 Eager Opportunist
3.4 Cruel Brigand
3.4 Starfall Servant
3.2 Flaming Sword
3.0 Kraken’s Hatchet
3.0 Tormund’s Horde
3.0 Wall-Bound Knight
2,6 Stony Shore Thrall
2.6 Vengeful Lordling
2.6 Abel’s Washerwoman
2.4 Nightfort Ruins
2.4 Desert Freerider
2.2 Tommen Baratheon

That’s part 2 down! See you again soon for part 3 with the remaining draft pack cards!

You may also like

Subscribe
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Mastodon
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x