Hey Thrones Community,
With Stahleck 2026 around the corner, it’s been almost a full year of playing with the Tower of Joy Draft Set. The reception to the set has honestly blown me away and I’ve been thrilled to see so many people draft over the year.
Last year, just before launch, five players rated all the new cards according to their expectations from various stages of playtesting. Since then, everyone has experienced the set in action and some cards even got some slight adjustments in the 2026 print run. To see how last year’s reviews hold up, I’ve once again gathered five players โ all of which have had success playing several drafts since then. Let’s see which cards over- or underperformed last year’s expectations, which ones were rated accurately, and which ones ended up controversial!
Once again, we’re rating cards on a 1-5 scale representing how likely you will end up including each card in your draft deck. Hereโs the scale with some examples from the Valyrian Draft Set for comparison:
5 โ A very powerful card that will almost always make the cut in your final deck. Either a standalone wincon or incredible utility. Examples: Feast or Famine, Victarion Greyjoy
4 โ A buildaround wincon, good standalone body, or a helpful but fair utility card youโre happy to play in most decks. Examples: Arya Stark, Silent Sisters
3 โ A perfectly playable card that you wonโt mind picking and playing most of the time but wonโt win you the game on its own. Examples: Even Handed Justice, Red Cloaks
2 โ Mediocre filler card that will often end up getting cut unless youโre short on playables or have some specific synergies that it enables. Examples: Salty Navigator, Unsworn Apprentice
1 โ Bad filler that you actively want to avoid picking and playing in your deck. Examples: Without His Beard, Crone of Vaes Dothrak
Additionally the pre-release averages will be noted alongside the new ratings like this: (2.4 ↗️ 3.6)
With that out of the way, let’s take a look at the Draft Starter!
Agendas
Sealing the Pact (4.0 ↘️ 3.4)

Werner – 2 out of 5
While it’s probably fair game to draft two houses only, you will struggle most of the time to draft characters evenly enough to consistently pull this off. Plus, you want to run as little neutral characters as possible (Neutrals are not out-of-faction).
Sara – 4 out of 5
Sealing the Pact seems a pretty strong option when you are happy with only one additional faction. You could not find that much power gain in the draft, so it would make it that more impactful and maybe worth including some suboptimal filler cards. I still found it a bit too limiting to give it full points. Besides having two factions to choose from, you also need to have a decent balance of both to really be worth taking.
Ululak – 4 out of 5
A power every round you meet the conditions is strong. Usually possible to build a solid deck with 2 factions. IMO better to have more out-of-faction characters than in-faction.
Xelcor – 3 out of 5
Only agenda that gives you power, but you give up some flexibility.
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 4 out of 5
I still think this is a very solid agenda, but after playing the draft set a lot, the restriction of running only two factions is definitely a bigger downside than I initially thought. You wonโt have any trouble finding enough cards in two factions to fill out your deck, but limiting yourself to two means youโll definitely be passing up some powerful cards either in the draft or in deckbuilding.
Unknown and Unknowable (3.0 ↗️ 4.8)

Werner – 5 out of 5
My favourite agenda in draft. It brings massive flexbility in deckbuilding and playing. For deckbuilding you will have a lot of excess cards most of the time and can really build a strong deck as you do not need to include bad filler cards. Sometimes you might even play a certain faction for a single strong card and play no other cards from that faction. Further, being able to give a trait is great in this draft pool (e.g. for Knight of Flowers, The Warrior, Jinglebell, …)
Sara – 5 out of 5
So far this is my favourite agenda to play. Allowing for two additional factions gives you more flexibility than other agendas without a downside. Trait manipulation is not something I ever set out to build around, but I still always found some good uses for it.
Ululak – 5 out of 5
Strong, most versatile to pivot throughout the draft, and fun interactions coming off giving a trait just when you need it.
Xelcor – 4 out of 5
Gaining a trait of your choice is great, plus two extra factions.
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 5 out of 5
After some time, this agenda has emerged as my favorite of the bunch. Not only does it feel great to be able to combine your best picks from three different factions, but the trait manipulation allows for some extremely fun and creative combos. Breaking the game is fun, right? Right?
Pass Beneath the Shadow (3.0 ➡️ 3.0)

Werner – 4 out of 5
Strong agenda, but you need to find the right cards to consistently trigger your agenda, e.g. Old Tattersalt is great for that. Further, finding some additional economy would probably also be necessary.
Sara – 2 out of 5
Shadows seem pretty hard to build for in draft format. The econ plots (and just econ in general) are much more limited and shadows are very expensive. Then you probably want some stronger reset than the starter ones and they are all rare. And then you still need to get the impactful shadow cards. All that said, if you find the cards the agenda seems really fun and good value.
Ululak – 3 out of 5
Very strong if you’ve picked the right shadows cards to finance your game. But can leave you stranded mid-way through the draft and then the deck gets slow and expensive.
Xelcor – 3 out of 5
If you get the shadow cards its great, probably a 4, but if not it’s not really good.
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 3 out of 5
I love this agenda, and I think itโs very strong in a vacuum. The issue is that the shadows archetype is very expensive, and in this format that definitely restricts its power level a lot. There are definitely strong shadows decks that you can draft, but you need to be sure to pick up some money plots and ideally an extra reset or two in the draft.
Seeking Fortunes (3.4 ↘️ 2.8)

Werner – 2 out of 5
Never seen this agenda in action, to be honest. But that probably says already how hard it is to build something around this. It’s maybe rather a scenario where you basically draft a mono-faction deck and sprinkle in a few cards from other factions. But then again, it might be easier to play Unknown and Unknowable.
Sara – 3 out of 5
Iโm not a fan of bestow in general, so I canโt say I have much experience with this agenda, but from playing against it seems pretty decent. The pool of cards you can include is a bit limited and in comparison with Free Companies needing to use your gold instead of moving it from the treasury is a significant downgrade. On the other hand, it does offer the flexibility of using it as econ.
Ululak – 3 out of 5
Location flex is probably underrated. Fun bestow interactions in the draft pool, often around similar traits, so lets pivot to other agendas midway, but with risk to misbuild.
Xelcor – 3 out of 5
Same as Pass Beneath the Shadow, depends if you draw the good ones.
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 3 out of 5
This is the agenda I think Iโve played the least. Iโd like to change that, but my gut feeling is that this is on the weaker side of the agenda pool. If you can draft a good amount of non-limited economy locations, thatโs the thing that will make this agenda sing, I suspect.
Join Forces (3.8 ↗️ 4.4)

Werner – 5 out of 5
There are a lot of strong Knights in the draft set which makes this an extremely strong agenda. But also builds like Army would work well with this agenda. There might even be viable The Seven decks out there.
Sara – 4 out of 5
It has some pretty good options of what trait to build around. However, I always ended up choosing Unknown and Unknowable over Join Forces. Even when drafting for one trait, a lot of the support for some traits will come from events, locations or cards that donโt share the trait, so not having that flexibility was usually more of a downside than having access to all X trait characters. But the plus side is the econ, so itโs still a good option if you have an expensive deck.
Ululak – 4 out of 5
Strong with Knights, Armies, Mercenaries and Raiders running deep in the pool and a good eco boost. See consistently good decks, but find itโs a rather boring agenda.
Xelcor – 4 out of 5
Way easier to build a deck and the cost reduction helps a lot.
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 5 out of 5
Realistically I think this is probably the strongest agenda from a power level perspective. Drafting Knights or Armies is pretty easy to do during the draft, and in a format where economy can be so tight, just having an agenda that gives you +1 gold from the start is extremely strong. Unfortunately itโs also a little boring, but hey, winning is fun too.
Desperate Hope (1.2 ➡️ 1.2)

Werner – 2 out of 5
Most of the time I guess a back-up agenda to make sure that it is almost impossible to not be able to build a legal deck after drafting. Giving it a two because there seem to be builds around pillage that can make this agenda work.
Sara – 1 out of 5
I know people have had success with this, but I hate everything about it.
Ululak – 1 out of 5
Access to everything but penalties are rough. Haven’t seen a competitive deck yet and will keep avoiding until desperate enough.
Xelcor – 1 out of 5
It’s bad. It is never the correct choice; it’s purely to challenge yourself.
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 1 out of 5
Iโve never seen someone actually play this. Theoretically it could work if you somehow get passed a bunch of really strong stuff that synergizes, but the minus 1 gold hurts so much. And realistically your deck will just be better if you pick three factions and play U&U. Please donโt play this agenda.
Draw Deck Cards
Reminder: You have a full 3 copies of each of these available in the Draft Starter.
Faceless Man (3.4 ↘️ 1.8)

Werner – 2 out of 5
Filler card if you did not draft enough characters for your build. Bad for setup and even after that a mono-con with a trait that rarely does anything for you.
Sara – 2 out of 5
Faceless Man seems pretty useless to me, unless you really had bad luck finding anything better. A lot of the โpopularโ traits donโt really do that much on a non-unique monocon and he canโt be set up. In most cases you should be able to find a better card to put in the deck.
Ululak – 2 out of 5
2-cost wildcard that can smooth Join Forces, Sealing the Pact and trait payoffs. Normally find better 2-cost bodies so never played it. Maybe I just donโt know how yet.
Xelcor – 1 out of 5
They always go out in the end, if they stay you had a bad draft.
Haruspex – 2 out of 5
Not as big of a fan of this guy as I initially thought. Heโs . . . fine. But itโs not that difficult to draft enough 2-cost guys for a deck, and most of the draftable 2-costers are better than him. In the decks where I did run him, it was mostly for the trait flexibility than the icon.
Pentoshi Trader (5.0 ➡️ 5.0)

Werner – 5 out of 5
I do not see a reason why I would not play three of them all the times. Economy, claim soak, good for setup.
Sara – 5 out of 5
Not much to be said. An easy include in every deck.
Ululak – 5 out of 5
Reducer and body. Three copies in pretty much every deck.
Xelcor – 5 out of 5
always 3
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 5 out of 5
If youโre not running all three, youโre wrong.
Holdfast Village (5.0 ➡️ 5.0)
Werner – 5 out of 5
I do not see a reason why I would not play three of them all the times. Economy, good for setup plus emergency gold during challenges phase if needed. Plus card draw.
Sara – 5 out of 5
Same as Pentoshi Trader.
Ululak – 5 out of 5
Reduces anything, including marshaling into shadows (I keep forgetting), and can later be cashed in for a gold or a card. Auto-include 3 copies.
Xelcor – 5 out of 5
always 3
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 5 out of 5
Economy – you really need it. Always run all three of these.
Market Square (4.2 ↗️ 4.6)

Werner – 5 out of 5
I do not see a reason why I would not play three of them all the times. Economy, good for setup.
Sara – 4 out of 5
Market Square is also an auto include, however, it gets a minus point for being worse than Holdfast Village in most cases.
Ululak – 4 out of 5
Burst of 2 gold whenever you need it, also for bestow or shadow. One-shot only, so it’d be the first econ card to cut if you draft too much economy (which almost never happens).
Xelcor – 5 out of 5
always 3
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 5 out of 5
Same here, always a 3-of. Itโs interesting how a lot of the economy in this format is bursty – you use it once and then itโs gone. It makes the econ curve of the game very dynamic and interesting in my opinion. And it also makes high gold plots extremely strong.
Plots
Reminder: You have 1 copy of each of these available in the Draft Starter.
Feast or Famine (4.0 ↘️ 3.4)

Werner – 3 out of 5
Backup card in case you did not manage to draft any good economy plot. Might also end up in your deck if you build for aggro.
Sara – 4 out of 5
A flexible plot option that is always available to you. If I think I will mostly be using it for econ I would still prefer to have any of the 6 gold plots or only use Manning, but itโs nice to have it as a back up or to keep the option to use the claim raise.
Ululak – 3 out of 5
A 7-gold opener or a 2-claim hit later, with 5 initiative. The 0-claim gold mode is nice in T1 with a high chance to win initiative. But somehow I never played it.
Xelcor – 4 out of 5
Most solid pure gold plot and can work as a finisher, but sometimes you can draft better.
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 3 out of 5
This plot is still solid, but I usually find myself cutting it for better plots in most of my decks. The flexibility is nice, but you can usually run a better opener than this in most builds.
The Pale Mare (4.8 ↘️ 4.6)

Werner – 5 out of 5
As for Valar Dohaeris in standard joust, strong reset that gets rid of your opponents big guys. Always in consideration for the reset option.
Sara – 4 out of 5
From my experience this seems to be the default draft reset. The other option has more counterplay and could backfire, and getting one of the other non-starter resets is not at all guaranteed.
Ululak – 5 out of 5
4-gold reset that keeps 10 printed cost of your characters and kills the rest, with no saves. Every deck plays it or has to play around it; initiative is the only real downside.
Xelcor – 4 out of 5
Depends how your deck is built, but most often a solid choice. You basically always have to play around it or be prepared to take the hit.
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 5 out of 5
This is the reset that will be in 90% of playersโ decks, so you need to be thinking about it when you build yours, and expecting it from your opponent. Itโs a great plot, you should be running it unless you have a compelling reason not to.
City Fair (3.4 ↗️ 4.6)

Werner – 5 out of 5
Provides draw, which is rare in this Draft Set. Makes the cut for me most of the times. Works great with Manning the City Walls.
Sara – 5 out of 5
For me the City plot line is by far the best, most reliable option. If you are lucky enough to find something like City Blockade to open with, this is especially good, but even without it itโs a solid opening that allows you to follow up with Manning.
Ululak – 4 out of 5
Solid 4-gold draw plot that makes the next City plot worth it (mostly Manning for getting that 6 coster on the board). Putting in almost any deck.
Xelcor – 4 out of 5
Mostly because it helps to have a City plot for Manning the City Walls.
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 5 out of 5
This plot, along with Manning, seems to be plot 1 or 2 in most of the decks I build. Mainly seems to be used as the enabler for getting the upgraded 6-gold effect from Manning, but if you open a better City plot to open with, you can save this for a later turn when you get to draw 2 cards. City plots are great in this format, donโt sleep on them.
Manning the City Walls (4.2 ↗️ 4.8)

Werner – 5 out of 5
Even if played as first City, strong economy card. Works great in combination with City Fair.
Sara – 5 out of 5
Manning is the best tempo you can get from a plot in draft, since you optimally get 10 gold value from it. Other options for tempo are Feast or Famine that sacrifices claim, or some of the rare plot cards that might be hard to find, so this seems like an easy include if you play 5 or 6 costers. It’s even still good with a 3 cost on opening and drawing two for City Fair.
Ululak – 4 out of 5
Gives 4 gold plus a 3-cost / 6-cost char into play in T2, so effectively the best econ plot in the starter. Needs a fitting character in hand, and only 1 initiative.
Xelcor – 5 out of 5
Best income plot, and even turn 1 a 3-coster isn’t the worst and better than Feast with no claim sometimes.
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 5 out of 5
Probably the most common opener I see, itโs basically 7 gold along with 1 claim, which makes it a strict upgrade to Feast or Famine. And if you can build your deck in such a way that allows you to consistently trigger the upgraded 6-gold version, itโs even better. 10 gold in this format can feel almost game-winning sometimes.
Razed to the Ground (2.8 ↗️ 3.2)

Werner – 3 out of 5
Solid plot in a aggro build. Otherwise probably does not make the cut.
Sara – 3 out of 5
Military pressure can be good especially if the opponent has a slower start, but I think Razed to the Ground lacks the flexibility to be a really good option.
Ululak – 3 out of 5
6 initiative and 2 claim on your first military challenge is a solid aggro plot – if you play an aggro deck. Else it doesโt make the deck usually; 4 reserve can hurt later.
Xelcor – 3 out of 5
Its decent but you might get better plots.
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 4 out of 5
Very solid plot if youโre playing an aggressive strategy. This would be slightly stronger if there were more aggro/attrition cards in the format, but you kind of have to hunt for them and intentionally build towards that.
Bitter Accusation (2.8 ↘️ 2.4)

Werner – 1 out of 5
Conditional draw / filter effect that only applies in challenge phase. To draw cards net, you would need to raise your claim. You can pull this off but then again, you would probable rather raise your claim on military most of the time if you run claim raise.
Sara – 4 out of 5
Between the three challenge type plots, I like using this one the most. The effect seems like the least impactful, but it has very decent stats and draw is not that common. Itโs especially nice if you find any of the cards that interact with the discard pile, and any claim raise is obviously a bonus too.
Ululak – 2 out of 5
5 gold and 4 initiative, but the text is just filtering (draw 1, discard 1) after an intrigue win unless you raise claim. Usually cut for better plots.
Xelcor – 2 out of 5
ehhhh
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 3 out of 5
I initially thought this plot was terrible, but Iโve since come around to seeing its usefulness – mainly, this gives you an easy way to seed your discard pile with your big 7-cost bomb character so that you can bring it out for free with Melisandreโs Gambit later. Not sure itโs very good outside of that specific interaction, but it at least has a place.
Royal Decree (3.4 ↘️ 2.4)

Werner – 3 out of 5
Solid plot to finish the game, gold and reserve is tough. Won’t make the cut for me most of the time for better alternatives.
Sara – 3 out of 5
On paper this seems incredibly strong, but I donโt know if I ever saw it played and I never ended up including it either. I guess the econ is just a bit too weak, but it could be very good to use in combination with Lady Whiskers in a low-curve build.
Ululak – 2 out of 5
7 initiative and a second power challenge make a good closer for power-heavy decks. But only 3 gold, which often is a disqualifier.
Xelcor – 3 out of 5
Decent finisher but you could get better.
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 1 out of 5
I really wanted to like this card better, but Iโve just never seen it played, really. 3 gold is just extremely punishing, and is very hard to justify.
Jousting Contest (3.2 ↘️ 3.0)

Werner – 3 out of 5
Solid plot, good gold and reasonable reserve. Has definitely some builds that this will be useful in, e.g. if you are running Willas Tyrell.
Sara – 4 out of 5
Probably overrating this a bit because I played a lot of Tyrell, which has some nice synergies. Overall it might not fit in so many decks, but it can be really good and itโs always available for when you see the cards you need for it to work.
Ululak – 3 out of 5
5 gold, and it turns the round into one-on-one fights, which favours a few big bodies over a wide board. Great with Knights, but not in every deck.
Xelcor – 2 out of 5
I rarely have seen it. Sometimes it helps, but you could get better plots for sure.
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 3 out of 5
This plot is decent if you build for it (or draft Tower of Joy) but overall I think there are usually better plots out there.
Biting Cold (3.6 ↗️ 4.2)

Werner – 5 out of 5
Strong reset that can win games if your opponent is running on a low cost curve.
Sara – 3 out of 5
It can be really impactful, cards going to the bottom is much harsher than even First Snow, but there are too many ways to play around it to be very reliable. Thereโs some good attachments in the card pool, some specifically for small characters, and you can also save with dupes.
Ululak – 4 out of 5
Strongly depending on character choice and cost curve, but can be great to clear the board for follow-up aggro especially where dupes arenโt that common.
Xelcor – 4 out of 5
Great reset and might not hurt you at all with multiple playstyles.
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 5 out of 5
Honestly an amazing card. You definitely have to build your deck around it, but itโs won me a lot more games that Pale Mare has. You can absolutely get demolished by this plot if you arenโt planning around it, so just be aware of that when youโre drafting all those cool 3-cost and under cards – Weenie strategies have a pretty big weakness here.
Secrets of Oldtown (2.6 ↗️ 3.0)

Werner – 5 out of 5
Provides great flexibility, especially if you are already running some trait synergies with Join Forces or Unkown and Unknowable. Note that you could also give your opponent’s cards a trait to mess around, e.g. if he runs Red Apple Knight.
Sara – 2 out of 5
Seems like the worst plot of the starter pack to me. I can see situational uses for it, but donโt really see space for this plot in most decks even if you are just using the plots from the starter.
Ululak – 3 out of 5
Decent gold and high initiative. Can go well with trait-based decks, but else a filler plot with no real upside to build around.
Xelcor – 3 out of 5
Situational but high iniative and can turn on some weird trait plays.
Ben Barnhart (Haruspex) – 2 out of 5
This plot is cool, but I rarely see it. Itโs best in an U&U deck where youโre already planning some trait shenanigans, I think. Critically you can use this card on an opponentโs character, unlike the U&U agenda, which makes for some fun combos if you get a bit creative (War Scorpion says hello).
Card Averages
Overperformers (up from last year)
Unknown and Unknowable (+1.8)
City Fair (+1.2)
Join Forces (+0.6)
Manning the City Walls (+0.6)
Biting Cold (+0.6)
Market Square (+0.4)
Razed to the Ground (+0.4)
Secrets of Oldtown (+0.4)
Underperformers (down from last year)
Faceless Man (-1.6)
Royal Decree (-1.0)
Sealing the Pact (-0.6)
Seeking Fortunes (-0.6)
Feast or Famine (-0.6)
Bitter Accusation (-0.4)
The Pale Mare (-0.2)
Jousting Contest (-0.2)
Card Averages
5.0 Pentoshi Trader
5.0 Holdfast Village
4.8 Unknown and Unknowable
4.8 Manning the City Walls
4.6 Market Square
4.6 City Fair
4.6 The Pale Mare
4.4 Join Forces
4.2 Biting Cold
3.4 Sealing the Pact
3.4 Feast or Famine
3.2 Razed to the Ground
3.0 Secrets of Oldtown
3.0 Pass Beneath the Shadow
3.0 Jousting Contest
2.8 Seeking Fortunes
2.4 Bitter Accusation
2.4 Royal Decree
1.8 Faceless Man
1.2 Desperate Hope
That’s it for part 1! If you enjoyed this review, part 2 will follow soon with a look at the 2026 edition Draft Packs!
